Shepard Fairey ripped off my picture first
Ed Nachtrieb took a picture of two Chinese soldiers in Beijing. That iconic image was used by Fairy in a poster. The comment thread is fascinating.
This is a discussion of copyright, citation, ethics and what exactly original artwork is. Fascinating and no doubt all of us have to keep an open mind going forward.
This is the annual report for Salon, one of the first and what used to be one of the best progressive magazines on the web: Form 10-K for Salon Media Group Inc.
Salon has a history of significant losses and expects to incur a net loss from operations for its year ending March 31, 2009. Because of past losses, an anticipated loss next year and a history of negative cash flows from operations, Salon’s independent registered public accounting firm for the years ended March 31, 2008, March 31, 2007 and March 31, 2006 have included a paragraph in its reports indicating substantial doubt as to Salon’s ability to continue as a going concern. During the last three years, Salon has relied on cash from bank debt, the issuance of convertible notes and preferred stock and from the exercise of warrants to meet its cash requirements.
Part of the story, although it’s hard to say how much of it, is the editorial direction of current editor Joan Walsh. A number of us who have been reading Salon for years (me since it’s founding) find her editorial direction inept. She spends quite a bit of time as commentator on MSNBC and brings some of that television mentality to what used to be a web site full of well considered, deeply thought, and well written pieces that took issues beyond typical television divisive sound bites. She doesn’t seem to know how to frame an issue in a way that helps her readers better consider it and get beyond it. She has been called a “concern troll” by many. She is a problem.
Salon has a community of commenters, one of the most articulate and outspoken of any that I’ve been involved with and large numbers of these people are now bailing: not commenting on current articles and not renewing their Salon subscriptions. Some of this is part of the trend cited in the annual report but some of it is a direct reflection of Joan’s mishandling of editorial control over the site. Her last post’s comments had to be closed because people were rioting: last page of comments on Betrayed by Obama. For the past year each of her pieces has at least one commenter (many have dozens) who states openly that as a direct result of Joan’s editorial leadership, they will not be re-subscribing to Salon.
One of those commenters has started a Salon Parody site and their latest post is the source for my post here: We’re Concerned About Salon’s Future.
All of this is a real shame because Salon has some of the best writers in the business, including the now infamous Glenn Greenwald and many others.
I still read Salon but not with the enjoyment of times past. It will be sad to see Salon go, we need all the articulate progressive voices on the web we can get.
[via Salon: The Parody]